Insider Chatter by Donna Bogatin

July 25, 2007

Valleywag Breakdown: Drunken Imagination

What is Valleywag “Managing Editor’ Owen Thomas managing? Apparently not verifiable truths in “reporting” on actual, tragic events.

“A drunk employee kills all of the Websites you care about,” Thomas headlines in good Digg-bait fashion, without caring to backup the accusation with reliable sourcing. A “tipster” is credited, as usual, but who knows, Thomas may even be “tipping” himself.

In his hard-hitting investigative series on the ripple effects of San Francicso power outages yesterday, Thomas also headlines “Angry mob gathers outside SF datacenter,” with photographic “proof”: eight mild mannered techies in casual business attire chatting on their cells while queing up patiently to enter an office building. (photo: Valleywag)

sf72507.jpg

Thomas’ own “take” on data center vulenerability is equally nonsensical: “What could bring your customers servers down” besides the actions of a drunken employee “fucking up a lot of stuff,” he purports. 

Cynthia Harris of 365 Main “cleared up the misinformation” with CNBC’s Jim Goldman (generally a Valleywag misinfromation fan!): “Any rumors about employee misconduct are completely unfounded.”

Thomas believes he has covered himself by including the prediction of just such a 365 Main denial along with his unfounded accusation of 365 Main conduct unbecoming. 

If Valleywag public stats are to be believed, Thomas has racked up more than 100,000 Digg-fueled page views with his utter nonsense. Who needs the Web’s truth, apparently, when Valleywag’s imagination is so much more appealing.

ALSO: Google: Data Centers Trump Rocket Scientists

CONTACT DONNA BOGATIN

Filed under: Ethics, Blogosphere, Blogs, Valleywag
Written by: Donna Bogatin @ 10:00 am

 

July 10, 2007

Valleywag: Lots of Ham, Where’s the Beef?

Valleywag’s bleeped headline yesterday is a tease, and so is Valleywag.

71107v.JPG

“F— you, Yahoo,” the rag’s Managing Editor headlines. Just like Owen Thomas can’t muster up the courage to go all the way where it counts in yesterday’s over promised, but underdelivered, supposed “scoop,” he buckled under Google (or Google fan boy) pressure in his inaugural attempt at Valleywag slumming: “Susan Wojcicki’s Big Lie.”

CNBC correspondent Jim Goldman reported on Thomas’ massaging of his first Valleywag “expose,” based on two not so hot sources, 1) public Google press releases from 2003 and 2) a USA Today reporter’s story published last week.

While he still maintains the gist of what he reported, and that Wojcicki “lied” about creating AdSense, he is changing his post to clarify the timeline of AdSense’s development. He says Applied Semantics released its version of AdSense in Oct. 2002. Five months later, Google unveiled a “copycat” version of its own, very similar software. And one month after that, Google acquired Applied Semantics and then named its system AdSense.

Thomas, though, is apparently not being upfront with Valleywag readers; The post contains no notice indicating any changes/corrections/modifications/updates following original publication. Surprising, given Thomas’s extensive editorial experience.

Thomas’s shock and awe Facebook headline today is also backed up by not so exclusive material: A publicly posted Facebook job notice.

What other “headline” scoops has Thomas dazzled Silicon Valley with at his new Valleywag gig?

“Jason Calacanis has no friends at Google” How so? A screenshot of Google AdSense ads served at Mahalo, bolstered by a Google PR statement.

“Google, Yahoo start from scratch” How so? A reposting of another Website’s reposting of a public screenshot of a Google sponsored student educational project, from eighteen months ago.

“Only half our users hate us” How so? A one paragraph “critique” of eBay CEO Meg Whitman, based on Bloomberg reporting. 

“Hello and Goodbye, Mahalo” How so? An Alexa screenshot.

Will it soon be “Ave atque vale, Valleywag”? To quote Thomas himself:

Bloggers are actually rather dull. People with something to say are intetresting. But actual ideas, knowledge and journalistic ehtics, alas, don’t come as part of the standard WordPress install. No wonder people are getting bored.

CONTACT DONNA BOGATIN

Filed under: Google, Ethics, Culture, Blogosphere, Blogs, Valleywag
Written by: Donna Bogatin @ 12:03 am

 

Powered by WordPress | Copyright Donna Bogatin | Contact Donna